skip to Main Content
Name: People v. Lopez
Case #: B182877
Opinion Date: 04/13/2006
Division: 1
Citation: 138 Cal.App.4th 674

Lopez, a Catholic priest, was convicted of multiple counts of molesting minors. During argument, the prosecutor made reference to Catholic priests committing “horrendous crimes,” asked the jurors to stand in the shoes of the victims, and expressed his opinion on the guilt of the defendant. The appellate court reversed the convictions, (and ordered a copy of the opinion sent to the State Bar), based on prosecutorial misconduct. Arguing guilt by association is misconduct, as is expressing a personal opinion on the guilt of the defendant. The error prejudiced appellant under People v. Watson, because the entire case was based on the testimony of the victims, without independent evidence or material admissions.