The Fourth DCA published this opinion to underscore its disagreement with the Ninth Circuits decision in Brown v. Mayle (2002) 283 F. 3d 1019 that 25 year to life sentences under the “Three Strikes” law for felony petty theft constitute cruel and unusual punishment. In this opinion, the court rejected appellants argument that his three-strike sentence for stealing a magazine constitutes cruel and unusual punishment. Given appellants criminal history, failure to comply with parole, and “due deference to the Legislature,” appellants sentence did not raise an inference of gross disproportionality.
Case Summaries