Trial court erroneously granted postconviction relief where the offense not “a direct result” (PC 236.15(g)(2)) of the defendant being a sexual violence victim. Defendant failed to establish the necessary “close causative nexus” between his victimization and the commission of the offense. Additionally: (1) review is governed by the abuse of discretion standard; (2) obtaining PC 236.15 relief does not require the defendant to prove he lacked intent to commit the underlying offense; (3) the requirement that the defendant committed the offense “while” he “was a victim” of sexual violence (PC 236.15(a)) is ambiguous but need not be resolved here. The concurrence affirmed on the basis defendant was not a victim “while” he committed the offense.
The full opinion is available on the court’s website here: https://www4.courts.ca.gov/opinions/documents/E083533.PDF
