Skip to content
Name: In re Alexander A.
Case #: D056674
Court: CA Court of Appeal
District 4 DCA
Division: 1
Citation: 192 Cal.App.4th 847
Opinion Date: 02/10/2011

The juvenile court's victim restitution order may be based on repair cost of property even if it exceeds replacement cost. The minor was adjudged a court ward for felony vandalism which resulted in damage to a school mural and a car. At the restitution hearing, the owner of the car submitted a repair estimate of over $8000, and said he considered replacing the car, which had a blue book value of $5300 for the same model in excellent condition. Defense counsel presented evidence showing the non-dealer purchase price of the same car in excellent condition was $4200,…

View Full Summary
Name: In re Robert M.
Case #: F060094
Court: CA Court of Appeal
District 5 DCA
Citation: 192 Cal.App.4th 329
Opinion Date: 01/28/2011
Subsequent History: Rev. gr. 4/20/11 (S191261)

A minor who commits a sex offense listed in Penal Code section 290.008 is eligible for DJF commitment even if that offense is not one listed in Welfare and Institutions Code section 707, subdivision (b). The Court of Appeal considered the interplay between the 2007 amendments to Welfare and Institutions Code sections 731 and 733. Section 731, subdivision (a)(4) allows DJF commitments for a section 707, subdivision (b) offense, if the minor is not otherwise ineligible under section 733. Section 733, lists ineligibility criteria, but subdivision (c) of that statute exempts from the ineligibility criteria those whose most…

View Full Summary
Name: In re Jose T.
Case #: A128020
Court: CA Court of Appeal
District 1 DCA
Division: 4
Citation: 191 Cal.App.4th 1142
Opinion Date: 12/20/2010

Before the juvenile court can impose a stayed DJJ commitment, the court must find that the previous disposition was ineffective in rehabilitating the minor and that the commitment will benefit him. The lifting of a stayed commitment cannot be automatic. The minor violated his probation by leaving his placement. A supplemental report recommended the current placement be continued because, except for that violation, the minor had been doing well in his placement. The court was going to continue the minor on probation until the prosecutor reminded the court that it had previously imposed but suspended a DJJ…

View Full Summary
Name: In re J.L.
Case #: G040507
Court: CA Court of Appeal
District 4 DCA
Division: 3
Citation: 190 Cal.App.4th 1395
Opinion Date: 12/16/2010
Subsequent History: rev. granted 3/2/11, (S189721)

Imposition of residency restrictions on a juvenile are so overwhelmingly punitive that a minor should be afforded a jury trial on the alleged sexual offense before the restrictions can be imposed. The juvenile court found the minor committed four lewd and lascivious acts. (Pen. Code, sec. 288, subd. (a).) As a result of the adjudications, and pursuant to Jessica's Law (Prop. 83), the minor faced lifetime sex-offender registration and residency restrictions. He was also potentially exposed to a civil commitment as a sexually violent predator. The minor argued on appeal that these consequences were so dire that due process…

View Full Summary
Name: In re E.O.
Case #: H035462
Court: CA Court of Appeal
District 6 DCA
Citation: 188 Cal.App.4th 1149
Opinion Date: 09/29/2010

A probation condition prohibiting the minor from being within 25 feet of a courthouse when he knew gang proceedings were occurring was unconstitutionally overbroad. The minor was found to be a juvenile court ward and placed on probation. One probation condition was that he "not knowingly come within 25 feet of a Courthouse when the minor knows there are criminal or juvenile proceedings occurring which involves [sic] anyone the minor knows to be a gang member or where the minor knows a witness or victim of gang-related activity will be present, unless the minor is a party in the action…

View Full Summary
Name: In re Shaun R.
Case #: H035112
Court: CA Court of Appeal
District 6 DCA
Citation: 188 Cal.App.4th 1129
Opinion Date: 09/29/2010

An order providing that all prior court orders not inconsistent with the current order remain in effect does not revive the appealability of the prior order which has already become final. The juvenile court sustained a fourth Welfare and Institutions Code section 602 petition and placed the minor on probation. As part of the disposition, the juvenile court stated that "[a]ll prior orders not in conflict remain in effect." The minor then tried to challenge some of the probation conditions imposed at the dispositional hearing on the third petition. The Court of Appeal held that challenges to those conditions were…

View Full Summary
Name: People v. Mendez
Case #: B217683
Court: CA Court of Appeal
District 2 DCA
Division: 2
Citation: 188 Cal.App.4th 47
Opinion Date: 09/01/2010

A sentence rendering a minor ineligible for parole until well beyond his life expectancy when the minor does not commit a homicide or inflict great bodily injury constitutes cruel and unusual punishment. The trial court sentenced a 16-year-old gang member convicted of robbery and carjacking to an 84-year prison term. He argued on appeal the sentence was cruel and unusual punishment under Graham v. Florida (2010) 130 S.Ct. 2011 because it amounted to a de facto LWOP sentence. The court disagreed that appellant's de facto LWOP sentence should be reversed pursuant to Graham since that case expressly limited…

View Full Summary
Name: In re D. G.
Case #: A126655
Court: CA Court of Appeal
District 1 DCA
Division: 1
Citation: 187 Cal.App.4th 47
Opinion Date: 07/30/2010

A probation condition banning the minor from within 150 feet of any school he does not attend was unreasonable. Appellant was made a ward of the court for burglarizing a house, and the juvenile court placed him on probation. One condition prohibited him from coming within 150 feet of any school except his own. The minor argued the condition was unreasonable under the Lent test and also violated his constitutional right to travel. Recognizing the juvenile court's broad discretion in formulating probation conditions, the court nevertheless held there was no reasonable basis for the condition.…

View Full Summary
Name: In re D.J.
Case #: A125867
Court: CA Court of Appeal
District 1 DCA
Division: 4
Citation: 185 Cal.App.4th 278
Opinion Date: 06/03/2010

Allegations of probation violations were not contained in a "petition" within the meaning of Welfare & Institutions Code section 733, subdivision (c) and did not foreclose a commitment to the Department of Juvenile Justice. The minor was subject to juvenile court jurisdiction based on his admission to a petition alleging robbery, a serious felony. Subsequently the prosecution filed a 2006 version of JV-600, a Judicial Council form indicating a violation of section 602 and alleging that it was a supplemental petition pursuant to section 777, subdivision (a) based on the commission of a new offense, a burglary, which was a…

View Full Summary
Name: In re Eric. S.
Case #: A125758
Court: CA Court of Appeal
District 1 DCA
Division: 5
Citation: 183 Cal.App.4th 1560
Opinion Date: 04/23/2010

Victim restitution orders in delinquency proceedings may include amounts billed by an HMO for medical services even when the victim is an HMO member not required to pay for those services. The victim, a Kaiser subscriber, received medical treatment at Kaiser for injuries caused by the minor. Over objection that restitution should be limited to the victim's out of pocket expenses, the juvenile court’s restitution order included the cost of the victim's medical treatment by Kaiser. Considering the purposes of the juvenile restitution statute (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 730.6) which are rehabilitation, deterrence, and making…

View Full Summary