Skip to content
Name: People v. Jones
Case #: A168930
Court: CA Court of Appeal
District 1 DCA
Division: 1
Opinion Date: 11/21/2024

Any trial error regarding when an entry occurred during a burglary was harmless beyond a reasonable doubt given the verdict in this case. After the close of evidence, the prosecution raised a new theory of burglary, arguing defendant had the requisite intent to commit a burglary when defendant later entered the victim C.M.’s bedroom instead of when he first entered her apartment.  Any error regarding this new theory and the denial of a unanimity instruction was harmless under Chapman because of the jury’s true finding on the burglary circumstance attached to a count of sexual penetration in the kitchen; since…

View Full Summary
Name: Maxwell v. Roe
Case #: 06-56093
Court: US Court of Appeals
District 9 Cir
Citation: 628 Fed.3d 486
Opinion Date: 11/30/2010

A conviction obtained by knowingly perjured testimony is fundamentally unfair and a constitutional error resulting from the use of such false evidence by the government requires a new trial if the testimony reasonably could have affected the judgment of the jury. In 1979, Maxwell was charged with the "Skid Row Stabber" killings and convicted of two of the ten counts of first degree murder. In subsequent appeals, he contended that he was convicted on the basis of the perjured testimony of a jailhouse informant, that the testimony was material, and that the prosecution withheld material evidence regarding deals the informant…

View Full Summary
Name: People v. Tran
Case #: G036560
Court: CA Court of Appeal
District 4 DCA
Division: 3
Citation: 177 Cal.App.4th 138
Opinion Date: 08/31/2009

The trial court did not err in admitting evidence of appellant's prior conviction for extortion. Tran raised six issues in the appeal from his convictions for murder, attempted murder, and street terrorism. First, Tran argued that the court should have excluded the gang expert's testimony concerning his 1994 conviction for extortion. The appellate court rejected the argument, finding that the evidence was relevant to prove the substantive charge of street terrorism, which uses the phrase "pattern of criminal gang activity." Further, the balancing between probativeness and undue prejudice under section 352 weighed in favor of admissibility. Given the elements of…

View Full Summary
Name: People v. Masotti
Case #: C056320
Court: CA Court of Appeal
District 3 DCA
Citation: 163 Cal.App.4th 504
Opinion Date: 05/28/2008

The trial court can grant a new trial only on a ground raised in the motion for a new trial and is without authority to grant a new trial on its own motion (Pen. Code, sec. 1181). Appellant was convicted by jury trial of cultivation of marijuana and two counts of furnishing marijuana. He filed a motion for a new trial on the ground that there was insufficient evidence to support the conviction. The court granted the motion for a new trial on different grounds, i.e., stating that it was on the basis of instructional error,…

View Full Summary
Name: People v. Callahan
Case #: B167543
Court: CA Court of Appeal
District 2 DCA
Division: 6
Citation: 124 Cal.App.4th 198
Opinion Date: 11/18/2004
Subsequent History: 12/16/04: rhg den.

The principle of deference (that where a trial court grants a new trial based on prejudicial misconduct, the determination may be affirmed unless it constituted an abuse of discretion) applies with equal force to the granting of a new trial on the ground of ineffective assistance of counsel. Not only is the trial court's determination of prejudice subject to an abuse of discretion standard of review, but also the trial court's determination of whether counsel's representation was deficient is subject to the same standard of review, and not to independent review. Therefore, where the trial court found that…

View Full Summary
Name: People v. DeLouize
Case #: S108119
Court: CA Supreme Court
District CalSup
Citation: 32 Cal.4th 1223
Opinion Date: 05/24/2004

Appellant was convicted of multiple sex offenses, and following trial, filed a motion for a new trial on the ground that the trial court erred by instructing the jury in the language of CALJIC 2.50.01. The trial court granted the defense motion for new trial on the day set for pronouncement of judgment. The prosecution did not appeal. After the expiration of the sixty day period within which the prosecution could have filed its appeal, the prosecution brought a motion requesting reconsideration of the order granting a new trial. The prosecution argued there had been a…

View Full Summary
Name: People v. Avila
Case #: F042072
Court: CA Court of Appeal
District 5 DCA
Citation: 117 Cal.App.4th 771
Opinion Date: 04/08/2004
Subsequent History: Rev. den. 6/23/04

During his trial for second degree commercial burglary, appellant asked for a continuance because he was in serious pain from an old back injury. The continuance was denied. Appellant continued to complain about serious headaches, and maintained that he was unable to assist in his defense due to the pain. A motion for a mistrial was denied. Following appellant's conviction, he made a motion for a new trial because he had been "mentally absent" from trial because of the pain. In denying the motion, the trial court stated that it believed appellant was in pain,…

View Full Summary
Name: Hall v. Director of Corrections
Case #: 02-55758
Court: US Court of Appeals
District 9 Cir
Citation: 343 Fed.3d 976
Opinion Date: 09/08/2003
Subsequent History: None

Appellant was convicted of first degree murder based primarily on his confession, which was suspect as it contained untrue statements, and two documents provided by jailhouse informants. The jailhouse notes were admitted without testimony by the informant as to their authenticity. The snitch later confessed that he had altered the notes of the conversations to make them more incriminating. The state trial judge ordered a new trial, but the Court of Appeal reversed, finding that Hall had not proved the notes were false. The Ninth Circuit reversed, finding that the Court of Appeal's decision was unreasonable…

View Full Summary