Skip to content
Name: People v. Fraser
Case #: H028312
Court: CA Court of Appeal
District 6 DCA
Citation: 138 Cal.App.4th 1430
Opinion Date: 04/28/2006

Because a civil commitment proceeding under the SVPA has a nonpunitive purpose and is not equivalent to a criminal prosecution, appellant had no Sixth Amendment right to self-representation. The trial court did not err when it denied his Faretta motion prior to his recommitment proceedings. Further, even assuming there is a common law right to represent oneself in civil proceedings, or a statutory right to self-representation, any error would have been harmless here. The record shows that appellant would not have reached a more favorable result had he represented himself given the overwhelming amount of evidence against him. Further, there…

View Full Summary
Name: People v. Phillips
Case #: C048887
Court: CA Court of Appeal
District 3 DCA
Citation: 135 Cal.App.4th 422
Opinion Date: 01/03/2006

During appellant's Marsden motion, he stated that "I feel maybe I should represent myself" because his attorney was not representing him properly. He also said that "maybe I could do better myself." The judge proceeded to hold a Faretta hearing. At that hearing, the court found that appellant had made an unequivocal request to represent himself. However, following a further colloquy, appellant agreed to continue with the attorney that he had. On appeal, he contended that the trial court erred by denying his Faretta motion after finding that he had made an unequivocal request to…

View Full Summary
Name: Moon v. Superior Court
Case #: G035456
Court: CA Court of Appeal
District 4 DCA
Division: 3
Citation: 134 Cal.App.4th 1521
Opinion Date: 12/20/2005

Because the magistrate deprived the defendant of his constitutional right to represent himself, the superior court should have granted his motion to dismiss the information. During his preliminary hearing, the defendant asked the court to either appoint new counsel or permit him to represent himself. During questioning the defendant made it clear that his preference was to represent himself. The magistrate denied the request because it would disrupt the proceedings and because the defendant had not shown that present counsel was inadequate. At defendant's insistence the court then held a Marsden hearing, ultimately denying the request to…

View Full Summary
Name: Hirschfield v. Payne
Case #: 04-35437
Court: US Court of Appeals
District 9 Cir
Citation: 420 Fed.3d 922
Opinion Date: 08/22/2005

Reversal on Faretta grounds: Hirschfield moved to discharge his court appointed attorney and represent himself because he stated it was the only way he was going to get the defense he required. He stated that although it was the day before trial, the motion was not a delaying tactic. The court denied the motion on the ground that Hirschfield was engaged in a pattern of delay and was either trying to get a new attorney or delay his trial. Two weeks later, the trial had still not begun, and Hirschfield renewed his motion. The trial judge…

View Full Summary
Name: People v. Percelle
Case #: H026115
Court: CA Court of Appeal
District 6 DCA
Citation: 126 Cal.App.4th 164
Opinion Date: 01/31/2005
Subsequent History: Revw. den. 4/27/05

Where a defendant moved mid-trial to represent himself because he was unhappy with counsel’s performance, the court did not err in requiring the defendant to make a Marsden showing even though defendant made an unequivocal Faretta request. An untimely motion for self-representation is subject to the trial court’s discretion, and although the court improperly structured the inquiry as a Marsden proceeding, the procedure resulted in an adequate record on which the appellate court could determine that there was no abuse of discretion. Second, where the prosecution improperly alleged as a prior prison term a count that had been…

View Full Summary
Name: Marshall v. Taylor
Case #: 03-56836
Court: US Court of Appeals
District 9 Cir
Citation: 395 Fed.3d 1058
Opinion Date: 01/13/2005

Marshall asked to represent himself on the morning of his state court trial. The trial court denied his request on the impermissible ground that he lacked the requisite skill and knowledge to represent himself. The appellate court affirmed on the proper ground that his request was untimely. In his habeas corpus petition, Marshall contended that the appellate court's decision was contrary to Faretta and that the finding of untimeliness was unreasonable. The Ninth Circuit disagreed and affirmed the district court's denial of the habeas petition. Marshall made his request to represent himself on the day…

View Full Summary
Name: United States v. Hamilton
Case #: 03-50179
Court: US Court of Appeals
District 9 Cir
Citation: 391 Fed.3d 1066
Opinion Date: 12/13/2004

Questioning an officer at a suppression hearing when neither defendant nor his counsel is present requires reversal of the conviction. In a case involving multiple defendants, counsel for one defendant was absent during the conclusion of a suppression hearing due to a scheduling conflict. She indicated that she had been under the impression that the remainder of the hearing would consist only of redirect testimony related to one of the other defendants, but in fact about half of the testimony taken in her absence related to her client. Noting that a defendant need not show prejudice when…

View Full Summary
Name: People v. Richardson
Case #: B164991
Court: CA Court of Appeal
District 2 DCA
Division: 2
Citation: 117 Cal.App.4th 570
Opinion Date: 04/06/2004

The court did not err in failing to appoint counsel at sentencing when the defendant attempted to withdraw his waiver of counsel. The defendant represented himself at trial, and at the end of proceedings filed a motion for new trial citing his own errors. The court denied that motion, and subsequently also denied the defendant’s request for counsel at sentencing. The Court of Appeal held that this was not an abuse of discretion, since the request was made late in the proceedings and appeared to be the product of…

View Full Summary
Name: United States v. Mack
Case #: 03-10204
Court: US Court of Appeals
District 9 Cir
Citation: 362 Fed.3d 597
Opinion Date: 03/30/2004

Appellant represented himself at his trial for distribution of cocaine base. His behavior at trial was "obstreperous, contemptuous, and demonstrative of his unwillingness or inability to abide by directions" from the court. Appellant was warned that if his behavior continued he would be removed from the courtroom. He was subsequently taken from the courtroom, questioning of witnesses ceased, and he was precluded from making a closing argument. The court also precluded the prosecution from presenting argument. The jury was instructed, with appellant present, and the next day issued a guilty verdict. The appellate court…

View Full Summary
Name: Robinson v. Ignacio
Case #: 02-17298
Court: US Court of Appeals
District 9 Cir
Citation: 360 Fed.3d 1044
Opinion Date: 03/10/2004
Subsequent History: None

The defendant’s right to counsel was violated when the trial court denied his request for representation at sentencing. The defendant here had waived his right to counsel earlier in the proceedings, but requested the assistance of an attorney at sentencing. The Ninth Circuit held that the state court violated clearly established federal law when it denied that request, holding that the federal circuits have interpreted the Supreme Court’s Sixth Amendment precedent to mean that the right to counsel is so integral to the fair administration of our justice system that a defendant who has waived his right to…

View Full Summary